Hall of Fame Members (through 2009)
| Member | Team | Year |
| Team | Men's Basketball | 1966-67 |
| Olabunmi Akinnusotu | Volleyball | 2003 |
| Robert Antignano | Baseball | 1972 |
| Silvero Araujo | Soccer | 1989 |
| Denise Armstrong | Basketball | 1983 |
| Kevin Barlette | Men's Lacrosse | 2003 |
| Tom Bass | Tennis | 1969 |
| Ned Bohan | Basketball | 1975 |
| Arthur Boulet | Golf Coach | |
| Maira Bras-Benitez | Volleyball | 1995 |
| Bob Brown | Golf | 1990 |
| Wally S. Camper | Basketball, Baseball Coach | |
| Robert B. Carson | Golf | 1976 |
| Jennifer Carvalho | Volleyball | 1998 |
| Susan I. Crisafi | Basketball | 1984 |
| Robert J. Chuprevich | Basketball | 1972 |
| Arnold Collison | Basketball | 1933 |
| Beth Connealy | Basketball | 1996 |
| Chris Congdon | Golf | 1992 |
| Darin Dagle | Baseball | 1996 |
| Liz Davies | Basketball | 1996 |
| Meribah Dean | Volleyball | 1996 |
| Anthony DeQuattro | Basketball, Baseball | 1967 |
| Ernest M. DeWitt | Basketball | 1981 |
| Bill DiStefano | Baseball | 1998 |
| Brian Drought | Baseball | 1966 |
| Thomas F. Duffy | Basketball Coach | |
| Jason Eldridge | Baseball | 1999 |
| F. Robert Else | Basketball, Baseball | 1965 |
| Noelle Emmette | Volleyball | 1992 |
| John F. Feeley | Soccer, Basketball | 1976 |
| Thomas Folliard | Director of Athletics | |
| Dave French | Golf | 1989 |
| Anthony Garganese | Baseball | 1986 |
| Jim Gary | Basketball | 1971 |
| Philip Goss | Cross Country | 1981 |
| Donald Gray | Basketball | 1970 |
| James O'Hallet | Golf | 1983 |
| Robert Hathaway | Director of Athletics | |
| Lorraine Hudak | Volleyball | |
| Clarence Jarvis | Basketball | 1936 |
| Mark Jolly | Ice Hockey | 1977 |
| James Kusz | Basketball | 1978 |
| Stephanie Ladd | Basketball | 1989 |
| Roy Lapidus | Cross Country, Track | 1972 |
| Frank Lanning | Sports Cartoonist | |
| Heather Lopes | Basketball | 1996 |
| Ray Lyons | Golf | 1997 |
| Keith MacWhorter | Baseball | 1974 |
| Lori Mahler | Basketball | 1988 |
| Charlie Mandeville | Cross Country, Track Coach | |
| Karyn Marshall | Basketball | 1986 |
| Al Martino | Golf | |
| Dan Mazzula | Basketball | 1988 |
| Mike McKenna | Golf | 1986 |
| Ken McKenzie | Bowling | |
| Lionel Mercier | Basketball | |
| Jennifer Proud Mearns | Cross Country | 1982 |
| Scott C. Menard | Tennis | 1973 |
| Marcie Monaco | Volleyball | 1999 |
| Richard Mott | Basketball, Baseball, Track | |
| Shawn M. Nassaney | Cross Country, Track | 1998 |
| Roman Pavlik | Tennis | 1996 |
| Bob Reall | Contributor | |
| Fred Reinhardt, Jr. | Cross Country, Track Coach | |
| Ron Renaud | Contributor | 1981 |
| Luke Robustelli | Baseball | 1998 |
| Paul F. Seymour | Basketball | 1978 |
| James Silva | Golf | 1976 |
| Jon Sjogren | Baseball | 1988 |
| Thomas Smile | Basketball | 1968 |
| Ambrose Smith | Sportwriter | |
| David Sorafine | Basketball | 1976 |
| Charles R. Swanson, Jr. | Basketball, Tennis | 1935 |
| Diane Tedford-Pomeroy | Cross Country, Track | 1988 |
| Richard Tellier | Basketball | 1968 |
| Scott Trethewey | Golf | 1991 |
| Judith Watson Olmstead | Basketball | 1981 |
| Lyse Wante Lepine | Cross Country, Track | 1986 |
| Donald W. Wilson | Soccer | 1971 |
| Greg Wolyniec | Football | 2001 |
| Gary Young | Golf | 1988 |
